Education · Free
Carry Trades: Yield Income Meets Exchange-Rate Risk
Follow a fictional carry ledger through interest accrual, two conversion outcomes and a break-even rate to distinguish income from total currency return.
Image credit
Hypothetical one-year simple-interest ledger; costs and intermediate funding pressures are excluded.
FavAcademy · Original FavAcademy educational illustration; public use authorized
Public summary
Borrowing in a lower-yielding currency and investing in a higher-yielding one leaves an exchange-rate exposure unless it is separately hedged. A one-year fictional example earns interest abroad yet finishes below the amount owed at home after an adverse conversion.
Define the economic exposure
A currency carry trade is commonly described as borrowing in a lower-interest-rate currency and investing in a higher-interest-rate currency. The apparent attraction is the yield difference. The unresolved risk is that the investment currency may lose value against the funding currency, leaving less after conversion than the borrower owes. Interest income and total home-currency return are therefore different quantities.
Banque de France and BIS research discuss carry positions and their vulnerability to currency movements and unwinds. Those mechanisms do not create a universal expected profit or identify a suitable retail product. Policy rates, obtainable borrowing rates and actual investment yields can differ. This reading uses fixed fictional rates to isolate the arithmetic rather than suggesting that a quoted central-bank rate is a rate available to a customer.
Establish a fully stated ledger
Let H be the funding currency and F the investment currency. Borrow 100,000 H for one year at simple interest of 2%. At the end of the year, the amount owed is 102,000 H. At entry, one F costs 2 H, so converting the principal buys 50,000 F. Invest that amount for the same year at simple interest of 5%, producing 52,500 F at maturity.
Assume no fees, taxes, defaults, conversion spreads, margin calls or changes in rates during the year. These exclusions deliberately simplify the example; actual arrangements can include all of them. There is no additional borrowing beyond the stated funding loan and no claim that an investment yielding 5% is risk-free. Matching maturity dates is also an assumption, not something that can be taken for granted in a real financing arrangement.
Evaluate an unchanged exchange rate
If the final exchange rate remains 2 H per F, converting 52,500 F produces 105,000 H. Repaying the 102,000 H loan leaves a surplus of 3,000 H before the excluded costs. Under these particular assumptions, that equals the three-percentage-point difference between the stated investment and funding rates applied to the initial 100,000 H.
That simple result depends on the unchanged conversion rate and matched assumptions. It should not be extended to contracts with different compounding, day-count conventions, maturities or financing adjustments. A retail position’s overnight rollover may include provider charges and product-specific mechanics. It is not automatically equal to a published policy-rate differential multiplied by position size, and it can change over time.
Add an adverse currency move
Now suppose the final rate is 1.90 H per F. The investment still earns 5% in F and still matures at 52,500 F. But conversion now yields only 99,750 H. After repaying 102,000 H, the net result is a loss of 2,250 H before costs. The investment currency’s 5% decline in its H price has outweighed the apparent yield advantage.
The illustration follows the same foreign-currency investment into two final conversion branches: 105,000 H if the rate stays at 2, and 99,750 H if it falls to 1.90. Both branches face the same 102,000 H repayment. This makes the source of the different result visible. Foreign interest was earned in both cases; the exchange-rate translation changed the total outcome.
Find the arithmetic break-even rate
The final conversion rate needed merely to match the repayment is 102,000 H divided by 52,500 F, approximately 1.942857 H per F. Relative to the initial rate of 2, that permits a decline of about 2.8571% before the simplified result reaches zero. It is less than 3% because the exchange-rate movement applies to the enlarged foreign investment balance, not only the original principal.
This break-even calculation is not a protective boundary or a likely exchange rate. Costs would move it, and intermediate losses could matter before maturity. If financing is callable or collateral requirements change, a participant might be unable to wait for the final date. The maturity ledger therefore does not describe every path-dependent funding problem that an actual position can encounter.
Understand why unwinds can amplify moves
When many positions share a funding currency, a shock can lead participants to reduce exposure and buy that currency back. Leverage, margin requirements and reduced liquidity can intensify the adjustment. BIS analysis of the August 2024 turbulence describes such deleveraging mechanisms. The lesson is about vulnerability to coordinated position reduction, not a claim that the same event or currency response must recur.
Hedging the exchange-rate risk changes the economics rather than making the yield difference free. Forward prices and transaction costs need to be included, and contractual risks remain. This reading does not calculate a hedged strategy or assert that a forward quote will be available on particular terms. Keep unhedged carry, hedged investment and retail rollover concepts distinct when interpreting commentary.
Interpret carry as a bundle of risks
A complete assessment would examine obtainable funding, investment credit quality, maturity mismatch, conversion costs, liquidity, legal terms and potential collateral demands. The simple yield gap is only one component. A higher quoted yield can compensate for risks that a two-rate comparison hides. Neither historical calm nor regular interest credits guarantee that an adverse exchange-rate move will remain small.
For the fictional ledger, the unchanged-rate outcome is a 3,000 H surplus and the 1.90-rate outcome a 2,250 H loss. Both calculations use the same interest income and repayment. That is the central insight: earning carry is not the same as earning a positive total return. Understanding the distinction makes yield-based currency stories easier to evaluate without treating income as protection against price and funding risk.
Continue learning with Rate Differentials: Why the Higher-Yield Currency Can Still Fall and Margin Trading: Understand the Deposit Behind the Position.
Risk disclosure
Rates and currencies are fictional. Carry income can be outweighed by FX, credit, funding and cost risks; policy-rate gaps are not customer return quotes.